A Cape Cod Cafe for Every Kind of Cafe Lover
Cape Cod may be known for its seafood and ice cream, but it has a great, albeit less-publicized, cafe side. As a bed and breakfast, you can imagine we have a sweet spot for yummy pastries and coffee, so we’ve compiled a list of our absolute favorites and go-to orders at each to fuel the kindred-spirited, caffeine-crazed Cape Cod explorers. You genuinely can’t go wrong with any of these spots, so scroll on to find your next cafe obsession.
For the coffee fanatic: Snowy Owl
(7 Underpass Rd, Brewster) - This is the most recommended coffee shop on the Cape and for good reason. The founding couple’s love for coffee and attention to detail go into every freshly roasted and brewed cup and their unique pastry offerings. Be prepared for a line no matter how early you are, and know that you’ll probably be willing to do it again tomorrow! Check out their new location in Brewster or in Sandwich (which tends to be slightly chiller).
Our Order: Hot latte (unbelievably creamy and velvety), Zucchini Bread, and a New Yorker (basically puff pastry had a baby with a cream cheese everything bagel)
For the foodie: Sunbird Provisions
(85 Main St, Orleans) - This one gets our vote for best coffee shop meets breakfast/lunch spot! The menu is seasonal, super creative, and gets bonus points for being great with dietary preferences (not always a given on the Cape)! After heavily debating the menu, order at the cash register, wait excitedly for your order, and head around to the back of the shop to take advantage of their picnic area for a nice lunch al fresco.
Our Order: Bird Breakfast Tacos or Bahn Mi, Crispy Potatoes with Citrus Mayo, & (Don’t sleep on this one :)) Vietnamese Coffee
For the explorer on the go: Cape to Cape Espresso Bar
(6 Commercial Street, Wellfleet) - This outdoor coffee shop nestled into Wellfleet’s Main Street is the best of the Cape. Order at the counter and wait outside for your drink; this spot feels like the ultimate summer stop. Grab an afternoon pick-me-up as you wander around the quaint stationery, jewelry, toy, book, and clothing stores in the area, or grab a quick bite and drink to go to complete your beach day!
Our Order: Honey & Thyme Grilled Cheese or Black Forest Ham Toastie, Iced Vanilla Latte, and a homemade brownie
For the pastry lover: Blue Willow Fine Foods
(1426 Main St, Wellfleet) - This is THE reason to make the drive up to Wellfleet. Don’t let the size stop you; this tiny coffee shop packs a punch with its insane selection of homemade pastries. Think scones, lemon bars, massive cookies, zucchini bread, and brownies- pretty much whatever your sweet tooth can dream of.
From Brewster, meander up Route 6 to take in Cape Cod scenery the entire way, i.e., golden-lit marshes, sea coast views, cute stores, picturesque towns. Stop at Blue Willow Fine Foods to pick up the best type of afternoon pick-me-up before heading to Marconi Beach at the National Seashore for the perfect Cape Cod Afternoon.
Our Order: Iced Chai with Oatmilk and whatever type of scone they’re baking up- they come up with super creative flavor combinations and have yet to disappoint!
For the Trend Lover: Lighthouse Keeper’s Pantry
(173 Main St, Yarmouth Port) - This spot went viral last summer for its fluffy seagull coffee. Inspired by the classic New England sandwich, the fluffer nutter, the fluffy seagull is an iced coffee mixed with peanut butter syrup and lined with marshmallow fluff. If the dessert drink isn’t your speed, though, there’s plenty more to sample – like ice cream sandwiches, grab-and-go sandwiches and a wide variety of pastries, or take home one of their many uniquely flavored in-house jams. Enjoy your treats in their beautifully decorated space or sun-soaked patio.
Our Order: Fluffy Seagull (for the curious) and an Egg, Fig Jam and Goat Cheese Sandwich on an English Muffin
For the remote worker: Three Fins
(251 Crowell Rd, Chatham) - If you have the misfortune of having to work while you’re on the Cape, at least you can have the good fortune of heading to Three Fins to do so. They serve up delicious coffee and pastries all day in both of their inviting shops. Their Dennis location is in a warehouse-style space with lots of seating and a lounge area, and their Chatham location is in a very cool repurposed community pool space where all the seating is actually inside the drained pool! And if you’re lucky enough to be able to detox from your laptop while you’re on the Cape, take advantage of their board game selection while you enjoy a drink.
Our Order: Mexican Mocha (they specialize in coffee and chocolate roasting, so this is a no-brainer) and a cinnamon muffin. They also offer miniature sized pastries if you’re looking for just a bite.
About the Sea Meadow Inn: A boutique, 7-room bed and breakfast located in Brewster (inside the ‘elbow’ of Cape Cod). The Sea Meadow Inn was originally built c. 1780 by sea captain Isaiah Clark. In addition to being a private residence, it has operated as a Bed & Breakfast, Inn and even a Tea House at various times since the 1980s. Today, we are focused on providing luxury accommodations, delicious garden-to-table breakfasts, and a peaceful oasis for visitors to rest and recharge energies. Whether you are an annual Cape visitor or exploring it for the first time, we want to help you make the most of your trip.
Looking for information on a topic not included here? Just ask! Perhaps we’ll include it in a future post.
You can also refer to our ever-growing google map of recommendations, which includes restaurants, beaches, thrift stores and so much more!